← All News

Milk and pig contracts: what the Supply Chain Adjudicator did in his second year, and how to raise a concern

The Agricultural Supply Chain Adjudicator's second annual report, published on 3 November, covers July 2025 to June 2026: one formal complaint and 15 concerns raised in confidence, three processors changing contracts or proposals after his office stepped in, and eggs next in line for the same rules. Who the rules cover, what you can complain about, and the three ways to get in touch.

Milk and pig contracts: what the Supply Chain Adjudicator did in his second year, and how to raise a concern

The short version: the office that polices milk and pig contracts wants to hear from farmers before a problem becomes a complaint. The Agricultural Supply Chain Adjudicator (ASCA), Richard Thompson, published his second annual report on 3 November. Over 1 July 2025 to 30 June 2026 his office received one formal complaint and 15 concerns raised through its in-confidence channel. His message, repeated in the GOV.UK announcement: producers do not need a formal complaint to contact him, and can raise a concern in confidence.

The report is frank about why the formal number is so low. Producers told the office they fear raising concerns could damage the relationship with the buyer they depend on, and the report comes back to that fear more than once.

Who the rules cover

The ASCA enforces the Fair Dealing Obligations Regulations, which set what a purchase contract between a farmer and the business buying from them must contain. Two sectors are covered today, according to GOV.UK:

  • Dairy (cows' milk): new agreements from 9 July 2024, all agreements from 9 July 2025.
  • Pigs: new agreements from 13 August 2025, all agreements from 13 August 2026. Since that date every pig contract in scope has to comply, unless a qualifying seller has used their right to opt out.

Eggs are next. The report says proposals for the egg sector are at an advanced stage after consultation with industry, and that the office has already started working with it. Fresh produce is named as a later candidate.

What you can make a formal complaint about

  • having no written purchase contract at all;
  • something the regulations require being missing from your contract;
  • something in your contract that does not comply with them;
  • on a variable-price contract, the buyer not explaining within 7 days, when you ask, how a new price was worked out after a price review.

There is an order to it. The adjudicator can only investigate once you have raised the complaint with the buyer through the dispute resolution process in your contract and 28 days have passed. That step falls away if you have no written contract, if the contract has no dispute resolution provision, or if its procedure does not comply with the regulations.

If a breach is found, the ASCA can order the buyer to pay compensation, a civil penalty, or both. Buyers are legally required to cooperate with an investigation, and decisions can be appealed to the First-tier Tribunal.

Three ways to get in touch

  • In confidence: email ASCA-in-confidence@defra.gov.uk. What you send stays confidential and you can stay anonymous. This route cannot open an investigation on its own, but GOV.UK says the information helps shape the adjudicator's work and can change how buyers behave.
  • A formal complaint: fill in the ASCA complaint referral form and send it to asca@defra.gov.uk, with the details of what went wrong, your evidence, and whether you are seeking compensation, how much, and why.
  • Through someone else: a farming union or another representative can approach the office for you.

What happened when farmers did speak up

The report and the adjudicator's blog post give three dairy examples:

  • A farmer raised concerns, in confidence, about new terms that could stop them selling milk elsewhere. The office took it to the processor without naming the farmer, and the processor reissued the contract making clear farmers could still sell surplus milk to other buyers.
  • A conversation at an agricultural show led a farmer to report that their contract lacked provisions on payment and milk collection that the regulations require. Talking to the processor did not fix it, so the farmer lodged a formal complaint. The processor then amended the contract, committed to changing its contracts with other producers too, and the farmer withdrew the complaint.
  • Several farmers came forward together about proposed changes to pricing, quality assurance requirements and limits on processing their own milk, matters the report says were not directly covered by the milk regulations. Raised anonymously, the concerns led the processor to review and amend parts of its proposals and give producers clearer information.

The year behind those cases was a hard one. The report describes farm-gate milk prices falling from late 2025, and puts the pig producer's net margin at an estimated −£20.44 per slaughter pig in the second quarter of 2026, with feed around 60% of total costs. In the pig sector, some independent producers received termination notices as processors cut numbers.

The year ahead

The office plans more case studies for milk and pigs, work on industry codes of practice (at its dairy roundtable participants committed to an industry-wide code, and a pig roundtable in September 2026 discussed one), and clearer GOV.UK information on how to get in touch. Since 1 July 2026 the Groceries Code Adjudicator, who oversees how the large supermarkets deal with their suppliers, has also been sponsored by Defra, which the report says will help the two adjudicators work together.

Sources

This is a summary of the adjudicator's report and GOV.UK guidance, not legal advice. Your own contract and the regulations decide what applies to you.

How useful was this article? Be the first to rate this